A recent study has found that three out of Australia’s four aluminium smelters face a serious risk of closure under proposed shifts in energy policy, a development that could shake the entire nation’s economy and threaten thousands of jobs. Why such a speculation? The federal opposition has pledged to construct seven nuclear power plants across five states if elected, arguing that their modelled plan could be 44 per cent cheaper than Labor’s renewable roadmap.
This AI-generated image is for representational purposes only
So, what could unfold if the Coalition forms government and pushes this nuclear initiative forward?
Australia’s aluminium smelters are among the highest industrial energy users in the country. The Tomago smelter in New South Wales alone accounts for 12 per cent of the state’s total electricity use. As decarbonisation pressures mount, the industry is searching for dependable, low-emission baseload power. In theory, nuclear fits this requirement. However, Australia has yet to demonstrate any practical application. Rough estimates suggest that powering all four major aluminium smelters with nuclear energy would require around 3 gigawatts of dedicated capacity. That could mean:
- Three large-scale nuclear reactors, each generating 1 GW, or
- Six to eight Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) with capacities ranging from 300 to 500 megawatts.
Currently, coal-fired power stations such as Vales Point B, Gladstone, Yallourn, Bayswater, and Eraring still supply nearly half of the electricity to the national grid. However, these ageing plants are inefficient, polluting, and on track to retire by 2038 at the latest.
Even under optimal conditions, nuclear reactors in Australia would take a minimum of 15 years to become operational, according to projections from the CSIRO, the country’s top science agency. As of now, there hasn’t even been a formal construction start. Should work commence immediately, reactors would still take so long to complete that existing coal plants would shut down well before nuclear units are ready to take over.
Globally, nuclear construction has a long history of blowing past deadlines and budgets. Take the UK’s Hinkley Point C as a case in point—it’s now projected to cost three times more than originally promised (USD 90 billion) and arrive 14 years later than planned (2031 instead of 2017). Similarly, in the United States, the NuScale SMR project in Idaho began with expectations of delivering 720 MW at a cost of USD 3.6 billion. Three years later, the cost had ballooned to USD 9.3 billion, with output downgrading to 496 MW. The project was ultimately abandoned in 2023.
These examples come from nations with over six decades of nuclear experience, whereas Australia, in contrast, has none.
Another often overlooked factor is water usage. Nuclear reactors require vast volumes of water for cooling. A typical 1600 MW reactor uses around 2,000 litres of water per second—roughly equal to the daily water consumption of four households every single second. In a country like Australia, already recognised as the driest inhabited continent, this raises serious concerns.
With the increasing likelihood of drought conditions, the competition for water between nuclear plants, households, and agriculture could be fierce. Globally, 61 per cent of U.S. nuclear plants are projected to face water stress by 2030, potentially forcing reductions in output or even temporary shutdowns. The implications for Australia could be just as severe, if not more.
On top of all this, new modelling by Australia’s leading climate authority suggests that the Coalition’s proposed nuclear plan could result in an additional 2 billion tonnes of CO₂ being released into the atmosphere over time.
So, what are the alternatives? Australia has a diverse suite of renewable energy solutions already being deployed and expanded. Solar PV, wind, and hydro are at the forefront, supported by firming technologies like grid-scale batteries, which currently provide 1.4 GW of storage, with forecasts pushing that figure to 12.8 GW by 2050. Pumped hydro, with 1.59 GW already under committed investment, offers another viable option for grid reliability.
Meanwhile, demand response programs, such as the 200 MW emergency reserve scheme led by ARENA in New South Wales, enhance flexibility and help stabilise supply during demand surges.
Green hydrogen also shows promise. Produced via electrolysis using surplus renewable energy, this fuel can offer long-duration storage and clean firming capacity. The sector is already attracting over AUD 200 billion in investment commitments.
There’s also untapped potential in geothermal energy. While no commercial plants are yet online, South Australia’s geothermal reserves could contribute up to 6.8 per cent of baseload power by 2030 if developed successfully.
Bioenergy, derived from sources like agricultural residues and plantation waste, has been another steady contributor. In 2020–21, it accounted for 37 per cent of all renewable fuel consumption in the country and can be deployed in a dispatchable manner.
Finally, natural gas plants equipped with carbon capture and storage (CCS) offer transitional baseload options. Eighteen CCS projects are in development, aiming to capture and store 20 million tonnes of CO₂ annually.
In short, Australia doesn’t need to pin its aluminium industry’s hopes on nuclear. While it may seem like a silver bullet for delivering clean, steady power, the real-world challenges, from construction delays and cost overruns to water scarcity and inexperience — make it a risky bet.
Instead, a mix of existing and emerging clean technologies, grounded in Australia’s renewable strengths, presents a far more resilient and cost-effective pathway for powering the aluminium sector, and keeping jobs and industries intact.