A Global Trade Research Initiative’s (GTRI’s) flagship report on Friday has put the spotlight on a plethora of possibilities for the Indian Government to tackle US President Donald Trump’s reciprocal tariffs that can potentially hit the Indian trade setup hard enough. One of which has pulled many eyeballs, including the government itself — India can consider a ‘zero-for-zero’ tariff approach, which is practically lowering import duties on select products that it does not import in higher quantities from the US as part of the proposed Bilateral Trade Agreement (BTA).
On this note, government officials have revealed to a national media publication that the consideration was in full swing, and discussions commenced with stakeholders in sectors like automobiles and auto components, in which American imports cannot threaten domestic manufacturers on a large scale.
The report stated that the Indian government’s commerce department has simultaneously initiated communication with revolving ministries to identify products where on-duty concessions could be offered without damaging the local industry.
Context of the reciprocal tariff
President Trump has affirmed that the US levies low tariffs on imports while other countries impose higher tariffs and trade barriers on American goods. According to the president, this leads to a USD 1 trillion US trade deficit that also harms US domestic industries and, subsequently, employment opportunities.
The Trump administration presented the Reciprocal Tariff Plan on February 13 to address the adversity, allowing the US to raise tariffs on countries with a trade deficit. The first set of reciprocal tariffs is expected to be implemented in April 2025.
As cumulative trade between the US and India exceeded USD 125 billion in 2024, Indian businesses are concerned about potential losses. It is still unclear how the tariffs will be applied — whether at the product, sector, or country levels.
The impact may be lean if imposed at the product level (specific tariff lines), as India and the US may not trade exact products. However, if levied at the sector level, entire industries could suffer severe disruptions.
Potential impact anticipation by India
The Indian government is reckoning with the potential consequence of reciprocal tariffs presented by the US administration on its trading partners. The idea is to analyse India’s export contenders to evaluate any relative price edge and strategise consequently. “We have begun talks with line ministries,” an official told the media house.
India presently exports auto components worth approximately USD 15 billion (INR 1.2 lakh crore) to the US at zero duty. In contrast, auto parts imports into India are subject to tariffs ranging from 5 per cent to 15 per cent. The report reveals that this tariff discrepancy was flagged during an inter-ministerial discussion on the India-US BTA.
Both nations aim to exceed double bilateral trade to USD 500 billion by 2030 and conclude the first phase of a multi-sector BTA by autumn 2025.
India has, in the meanwhile, reported duty reductions on certain US exports.
In the Union Budget on February 1, New Delhi lowered tariffs on bourbon whisky from 150 per cent to 100 per cent. It declared cuts on imports of fish hydrolysate for motorcycles, scrap materials, satellite ground installations, ethernet switches and aquatic feed. These actions could potentially benefit American exporters.
The report also stressed that minimal trade of ready-to-drive electric vehicles (EVs) between India and the US, denoting that a duty respite in this sector may not immensely impact domestic players. “The US is a high-cost country, and there is no major American EV manufacturer operating in India. If duties are lowered, it may not lead to a flood of imported products,” an official has conveyed to the media.
Limitations of Zero-for-zero tariff
The Zero-for-zero tariff strategy violates the World Trade Organization’s Most-Favoured-Nation rules. The rule suggests that if a country reduces tariffs on a product for one member country, it must also reduce tariffs for the same products for all other member countries.
MFN is a cornerstone of the WTO’s multilateral trading system. The rule was created after World War II to replace policies based on power with a rules-based framework and prohibits different treatment for the same products based on the country of origin.
Still, why the consideration?
However, it is still less damaging than negotiating a full FTA, which could compel India to make tough concessions, like opening government procurement to US firms, lessening agriculture subsidies, debilitating patent protections, and removing data flow restrictions—all of which India is unprepared to accept. Furthermore, many trade issues mentioned in an FTA are already covered under the US-led Indo-Pacific Economic Framework (IPEF), of which India is a member.
Also, Trump’s tariffs on Mexico and Canada, despite the USMCA, indicate his scepticism toward FTAs. If the US vetoes the Zero-for-Zero proposal, tariffs will far from be the utmost challenge. Instead, these will be a golden opportunity to intimidate India into making concessions in other zones.
In such a circumstance, India should ideally decline any negotiations and retaliate against any ludicrous demands, taking lessons from China’s approach.
Information source: GTRI report and Economic Times