The European Union’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) was introduced as a bold step in the fight against climate change. It is meant to prevent carbon leakage—where companies move production to countries with weaker climate policies—by ensuring that imported goods face the same carbon costs as those produced within the EU. In theory, this levels the playing field for European industries while pushing other nations towards greener practices.
But there’s a problem: CBAM, in its current form, simply does not work for aluminium. Instead of protecting one of Europe’s most critical industries, it risks making it uncompetitive, increasing costs for manufacturers, and even worsening global emissions. Without urgent reforms, CBAM could do more harm than good.
An aluminium industry on the brink
Aluminium is the backbone of Europe’s green transition, used in everything from solar panels and electric grids to electric vehicles and aerospace. Yet, despite its strategic importance, European aluminium producers are being squeezed by skyrocketing energy prices, state-subsidised competition from China, and now, the unintended consequences of CBAM.
Europe already imports over 50 per cent of its aluminium needs. With the wrong CBAM framework in place, this reliance will only grow, undermining Europe’s climate ambitions, industrial base, and strategic autonomy.
Eivind Kallevik, President and CEO of Norsk Hydro, recently took to social media to convey, “The devil is in the details. This week, I spent two days in Brussels addressing a major loophole in CBAM’s rules for aluminium—one that risks undermining EU climate ambitions, security of supply, and the competitiveness of the European aluminium industry.”
So, what needs to change? Here’s what European Aluminium — the continental industry’s leading voice — is calling for.
Stop penalising clean aluminium — keep indirect emissions out for now
One of the biggest flaws in CBAM is its inclusion of indirect emissions—the carbon costs embedded in electricity prices. Because aluminium production is extremely energy-intensive, European manufacturers already pay high carbon costs under the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS), even when they use clean electricity. Their competitors outside Europe? They don’t face these costs at all.
If CBAM includes indirect emissions, European-made low-carbon aluminium will become too expensive, driving production abroad to places with dirtier energy grids. That means more emissions, not fewer. Until Europe’s electricity grid is fully decarbonised, unlikely before 2035, CBAM should exclude indirect emissions to prevent this unintended consequence.
Expand CBAM to cover more aluminium products
CBAM currently applies only to raw aluminium but not to finished goods like car parts, packaging, and building materials that contain aluminium. This loophole creates an obvious problem, wherein manufacturers will potentially import aluminium-rich finished products instead of buying raw aluminium in Europe.
To stop this from happening, CBAM should cover downstream aluminium products. Otherwise, Europe risks becoming just a market for foreign-made aluminium goods while its own manufacturers struggle to survive.
Keep carbon leakage protections in place — until CBAM proves itself
For years, European industries have been shielded from unfair competition by free ETS allocations and indirect cost compensation — two mechanisms that help level the playing field. However, under the current plan, these protections will be phased out, even though CBAM has not yet proven that it can prevent carbon leakage.
If CBAM does not work as intended, the EU must reconsider the phase-out of free ETS allowances. Removing them too soon would leave aluminium producers completely exposed to carbon leakage, forcing them to either shut down or move operations elsewhere.
Ensure European aluminium can compete in global markets
Europe’s aluminium producers export 10-15 per cent of their annual output, valued at EURO 7.5 billion. But, without a proper CBAM export solution, these businesses could struggle to compete. If aluminium produced in Europe is burdened with CBAM-related cost increases, while competitors in the US, China, or the Middle East face no such restrictions, European exports will become uncompetitive overnight.
Without action, non-EU buyers will have every incentive to source aluminium from regions with lower environmental standards. That means more emissions, fewer European jobs, and a weaker EU economy.
Fix CBAM’s emission reporting to prevent greenwashing
If CBAM is to work, it must be based on credible, transparent emissions data. Right now, the reporting rules are full of loopholes. For example, some non-EU countries may report artificially low emissions, while others use questionable Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs) to appear greener than they really are. Iceland, for instance, has been caught selling the same green electricity twice.
To prevent this kind of greenwashing, CBAM should adopt internationally recognised reporting standards, such as those from the International Energy Agency (IEA), and require third-party verification of all emissions data. Otherwise, unscrupulous exporters will game the system, undermining CBAM’s entire purpose.
Close the loopholes — stop resource shuffling and circumvention
If CBAM is poorly enforced, companies will find ways to dodge the rules. One common trick is resource shuffling, where exporters selectively direct their cleanest products to Europe while continuing to produce high-carbon goods for other markets. Another is importing aluminium scrap, which currently enters the EU with zero carbon cost, even if it was originally produced using coal-fired power.
To stop these dodges, the EU must:
- Ban the use of unverifiable RECs in emissions reporting.
- Require full value chain emissions reporting to prevent selective “greenwashing” of exports.
- Ensure CBAM default values reflect the worst-performing producers in non-market economies like China.
Cut red tape — end double reporting for EU producers
One of the most frustrating aspects of CBAM is that European aluminium producers must report their emissions twice—once under ETS, and again for CBAM. This is unnecessary bureaucracy that does nothing to reduce emissions but adds compliance costs for businesses already struggling with high energy prices.
The EU should remove CBAM reporting requirements for EU/EFTA-origin aluminium to prevent double taxation and streamline the system.
A smarter CBAM for a stronger Europe
CBAM could be a game-changer for fair trade and global climate action—but only if it’s done right. As it stands, the policy risks pushing European aluminium production offshore, increasing global emissions, and damaging the EU’s industrial competitiveness.
Instead of penalising European businesses that are already leading the way in sustainability, CBAM should be reformed to close loopholes, stop circumvention, and ensure fair competition. The European Commission’s upcoming 2025 review is a crucial opportunity to make these fixes before it’s too late.
If Europe wants to achieve its climate goals while maintaining industrial leadership, it must listen to its aluminium producers. The time to act is now.
Information Source: European Aluminium