BlogDownstream AluminiumEurope’s next budget: The EU cannot subsidise its way to prosperity

Europe’s next budget: The EU cannot subsidise its way to prosperity

Europe’s next seven-year budget is becoming much more than an argument about numbers. The negotiations over the European Union’s 2028–2034 Multiannual Financial Framework are exposing a deeper disagreement about what kind of economy Europe wants to build and how it should compete in a world increasingly defined by geopolitical rivalry, energy insecurity and competition for critical raw materials.

More than just numbers

The European Commission’s proposed budget is almost EUR 2 trillion (USD 2.245 trillion), equivalent to around 1.26% of EU gross national income. It is designed to finance a more competitive, resilient and strategically autonomous Europe, with major investments in research, innovation, clean technologies, digitalisation, defence and energy. Yet member states are divided over both the size of the budget and the priorities that should sit at its centre.

The divide is increasingly visible between northern net contributors and countries in southern and central Europe that remain heavily dependent on cohesion and agricultural funding. Germany, Denmark, Finland, the Netherlands and Austria have called for the proposed budget to be reduced by several hundred billion euros, arguing that taxpayers should not be asked to finance an ever-expanding list of European priorities. Their preferred approach is to shift resources towards defence, competitiveness, innovation, energy security and strategic investment.

On the other side are the “Friends of Cohesion”, a group of 17 countries concerned that reducing traditional EU spending would undermine regional development, agriculture and efforts to close the economic gap between richer and poorer parts of the Union. Spain and Italy, among others, favour maintaining strong support for traditional programmes and have been more open to additional EU borrowing or new common revenues.

Competing visions on the future of the EU

This is not simply a North-South dispute. It reflects two competing ideas of what European solidarity should mean. For one camp, solidarity increasingly means investing collectively in the technologies, infrastructure and capabilities that will determine Europe’s future prosperity. For the other, solidarity remains closely connected to redistribution: Namely helping farmers, poorer regions and less-developed economies catch up with their wealthier neighbours. Both arguments have merit. But Europe cannot afford to allow the debate to become a choice between cohesion and competitiveness.

Innovation, energy and raw materials demonstrate why

The proposed European Competitiveness Fund is intended to bring together 14 existing programmes and support investment from research through to commercial scale-up. Its priorities include digital technologies, clean transition and industrial decarbonisation, health and biotechnology, defence and space. Horizon Europe would continue to provide EUR 175 billion (USD 196.5 billion) for research and innovation.

This matters enormously for European industry. Europe has excellent universities, engineers and industrial companies, but too often struggles to translate research into globally competitive businesses. The challenge is not simply to invent the next technology. It is to manufacture it, finance it, commercialise it and export it. The same principle applies to energy. Europe’s industrial competitiveness cannot be separated from the cost and availability of energy. Energy-intensive sectors such as aluminium, steel, chemicals, glass and cement are particularly exposed. If European companies face structurally higher energy costs than competitors in North America, the Middle East or Asia, no amount of regulation or subsidy can permanently compensate for the disadvantage.

The EU therefore needs to view energy policy not only through the lens of decarbonisation but also through competitiveness and security of supply. Investment in grids, storage, nuclear where appropriate, renewables and other low-carbon technologies must go hand in hand with maintaining reliable and affordable industrial energy.

The raw materials challenge

Raw materials present an equally fundamental challenge for the EU. Europe cannot build batteries, renewable-energy equipment, semiconductors, defence systems or digital infrastructure without access to enormous quantities of minerals and metals. Yet many critical inputs are either imported or concentrated in a small number of countries. This creates a difficult policy choice. Europe understandably wants greater strategic autonomy. But strategic autonomy should not become synonymous with economic isolation.

The temptation to protect European industry through tariffs, local-content requirements and restrictions on imports is growing. Recent proposals from France and Germany for stronger EU trade-defence tools reflect concern about Chinese subsidies, dumping and restrictions on critical supplies. There is a legitimate case for defending European industry against unfair competition and economic coercion, but there is an important distinction between resilience and protectionism.

For an economy dependent on imported raw materials, closing markets can quickly become counterproductive. Europe needs more suppliers, not fewer. It needs diversified global supply chains connecting European manufacturers with producers of minerals, metals, energy and intermediate goods around the world. Trade openness should therefore be considered part of Europe’s raw-material strategy.

The EU should invest in domestic extraction, recycling and processing where economically and environmentally viable. At the same time, it should deepen trade relationships with reliable partners and remove unnecessary barriers to the movement of raw and secondary materials. A circular European economy cannot function efficiently if valuable resources are prevented from crossing borders to where they can be processed most effectively.

The budget is critical to the future direction of the EU

This is where the budget debate becomes strategically important. Europe does not have unlimited public money. The answer cannot simply be to spend more on every existing priority while adding new ones. The EU needs to become more selective, directing public investment towards areas where it can generate genuine European added value.

That means supporting innovation rather than simply subsidising established industries; improving energy infrastructure rather than compensating permanently for high energy costs; developing raw-material capacity while maintaining access to global markets; and completing the Single Market so that European companies can achieve scale. The danger is that Europe ends up spending enormous sums protecting yesterday’s economic model rather than financing tomorrow’s.

The new EU budget should therefore be judged not simply by how much money each country receives, but by whether it creates the conditions for European businesses to innovate, invest, trade and grow. North and South should not have to choose between cohesion and competitiveness. A successful European industrial strategy should make the two reinforce each other.

The ultimate test of the 2028–2034 budget will be whether it helps Europe become more productive, innovative and resilient while remaining sufficiently open to the world to secure the energy and raw materials that its industries need. Europe cannot subsidise its way to prosperity. Nor can it protect its way to security. Its future will depend on investing in innovation, securing competitive energy, building resilient raw-material supply chains and keeping the channels of international trade open.

Glen Hodgson
Glen Hodgson
Glen is the Founder & CEO of Free Trade Europa, an intergovernmental organisation that promotes free trade and economic integration. With over 25 years of experience, he is a recognised policy expert, commentator and corporate strategist, specialising in public affairs, lobbying and EU policy. He has an exceptional track record in business development across EMEA, delivering impactful programmes for multinationals, start-ups, governments and trade associations. His expertise spans the energy, environment, transport, and technology sectors, complemented by a deep knowledge of migration, trade, and labour market policy.
RELATED ARTICLES
- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Recent Comments