On Monday in Luxembourg, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen formally put a “zero‑for‑zero” offer on the table. The EU would eliminate its tariffs on US cars and other industrial goods if Washington reciprocates by dropping its own levies to zero. The proposal comes just days after President Trump announced a 20 per cent tariff on virtually all remaining EU imports and a 25 per cent rate on steel, aluminium and autos, a move Brussels says threatens integrated supply chains on both sides of the Atlantic. However, US President Donald Trump has declined the offer and stood by his previous decision, stating to reporters at the White House, “The European Union has been very, very bad to us; they don’t take our cars, like Japan in that sense, they don’t take our agricultural product. They don’t take anything practically.”
Image for representational purposes only
Rather than limit the pitch to vehicles alone, von der Leyen extended the scope to cover pharmaceuticals, machinery, rubber, semiconductors and more, essentially all industrial sectors. She stressed that the EU has offered similar automotive‑only deals in the past but received no adequate response and that this broader offer “remains on the table” as Brussels’ preferred route to defuse the dispute.
At the same meeting, EU trade ministers also agreed to launch retaliatory tariffs of 25 per cent on a curated list of US imports (initially capped below EUR 26 billion) should talks falter — underscoring that the EU is ready to defend its interests if negotiations stall.
President Trump, however, immediately rejected the zero‑for‑zero offer as insufficient to erase the imbalanced and unfair trade.
The transatlantic trade relationship is one of the most significant globally, with annual trade in goods and services exceeding EUR 1 trillion. However, the United States recorded a goods trade deficit of USD 235.6 billion with the EU in 2024, according to data from the US TraUS Representative’s office.
Among the total trade, over the period of 2018-2024, the United States exported a total of USD 2.05 billion worth of aluminium while importing USD 10.27 billion from the EU. This left the US with a cumulative trade deficit of USD 8.22 billion, meaning it brought in roughly five dollars of aluminium for every dollar it sent abroad.
In the same span, the European Union shipped out USD 2.80 billion in aluminium exports and took in USD 8.30 billion in imports. That resulted in a net deficit of USD 5.50 billion, with the EU importing about three times as much aluminium by value as it exported.
The US ran a much larger deficit (USD 8.2 billion) than the EU (USD 5.5 billion), importing roughly five times more total aluminium than what it exported, versus about three times for the EU. In 2018 - 19, US imports briefly dipped after the Section 232 tariffs were imposed, then rebounded as downstream industries (auto, aerospace) pushed for exemptions. The EU saw steadier growth in both flows, thanks to its internal single market and its Green Deal incentives for recycling and remelting. Both regions saw a slump in 2020 (COVID lockdowns), but by 2022–2 had not only recovered but, in the EU’s case, accelerated import growth to feed a boom in EV‑battery casing and renewable‑energy infrastructure.
- Why is the US so much more import-dependent?
When tariffs on aluminium hit in mid-2018, many US smeUSers were already running at half‑capacity, shuttered by high energy costs and stiff global competition. The result: domestic producers simply couldn’t keep pace with the resurgence in automotive‑sector demand (lightweighting initiatives in Detroit) and a nascent aerospace recovery. By 2021, US buyers were back to sourcing over USD 1.3 billion a year.
- How did the EU narrow the gap?
Meanwhile, Brussels poured subsidies into recycled aluminium “circular” projects, helping boost export capacity in Belgium, Germany and Scandinavia. EU refiners also capitalised on cheaper hydro‑power in the Nordic countries to cut production costs. That allowed the EU to ship out roughly USD 400 million of aluminium per year (on average)—about 20 per cent more than the US — and keep its import bill lower relative to exports.
Both economies remain net importers, but the EU’s stronger recycling push and internal market efficiencies have kept its aluminium trade deficit under tighter control. The US, by contrast, will likely stay reliant on cross‑border flows until new green‑hydrogen smelters come online or until a fresh round of trade negotiations unlocks more capacity at home.
“The EU has been very tough over the years. It was formed to do damage to the United States in trade. It was formed with all of the countries from Europe. I guess most of them, not all of them, but most of them formed together to create a little bit of a monopoly situation to create a unified force against the United States trade. They’re sending millions and millions of cars into the US, but we don’t have a car that’s been sold to the European Union or other places,” Trump reciprocated during an earlier bilateral meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the White House.
The new set of tariffs, scheduled to take effect on April 9, targets key European exports such as automobiles and machinery.
Donald Trump has, at the end, argued that the trade deficit could only be addressed if European countries committed to purchasing American energy products. The US president suggested that such an agreement must be worth USD 350 billion, far exceeding the actual deficit, to resolve the issue.