Nalco’s short-term outlook remains weak

Government-owned Nalco saw its stock price hitting a 52-week low of INR 32.50 on Thursday, almost half the INR 63.50 on July 4 last year. While the weak outlook for base metals has been responsible, lack of backward integration of coal and the Offer for Sale by the government in March have also acted as a dampener.

While the company continues to seek captive coal supplies, it is also optimising the cost of production through use of linkage coal and by curtailing production. Aluminium output at 98,000 tons was down two per cent sequentially and six per cent year-on-year owing to production cuts, in the wake of weakness in the prices. While aluminium production consumes more power, prices of the metal on the London Metal Exchange (LME) remain weak, leading to low profitability. The strategy so far has been successful. Thus, power and fuel costs as a percentage of sales during the March quarter had declined to 27 percent versus 35 percent in the December 2012 quarter. The aluminium segment also reported a profit at the EBIT (earnings before interest and tax) level for the first time after seven quarters of losses.

Nalco has also been pushing up merchant sales of alumina to drive revenues. The bauxite mining issues, on the back of delays in the licence renewal, had been sorted in December. Alumina output at 306,000 tons in the March quarter had increased substantially compared to the 220,000 tons produced in the December 2012 quarter. On a year-on-year basis, alumina production was up 11.7 percent. Consequently, the company was able to beat consensus estimates on profitability.

The strategy of cutting aluminium production and optimising costs is working but it remains to be seen how much it will help in the coming days. Aluminium prices on the LME have declined further to $1,800-1,900 a ton from an average of a little over $2,000 in the March quarter.

For about 18 months, the company will have to depend on coal linkages and other sources to meet its coal requirements, as it expects to commence mining in the Utkal E block only by December 2014. Thus, the near-term environment remains challenging. Giriraj Daga at Nirmal Bang Equities says, though, that the downside for the stock would be limited. However, triggers for a substantial upside are still missing.